You Say It’s Okay to Make Mistakes. What Happens When They Actually Do?
They turn the ball over.
The coach says immediately: “It's okay. Next play.”
Exactly what you would hope to hear.
The athlete sprints back on defense.
Twenty seconds later, play stops.
Substitution.
They sit down on the bench.
Up in the stands, one parent tilts their head back for a second. They may not even realize they did it.
A teammate checks in.
When the player returns later, the ball seems to come their way a little less often.
Nobody said: “Don't make another mistake.”
And yet there is a good chance the message still landed.
Because young athletes don't learn how safe it is to make mistakes only from what we tell them.
They learn from what happens next.
“It's okay. Next play.”
At least when it comes to what we say, youth sports have learned a lot of good things.
We say mistakes are part of the process.
That athletes need courage.
That we don't want robots.
That we want kids who make decisions.
That we want creativity.
That they need to try.
And we probably mean all of it.
The problem begins when the ball is actually turned over.
When the risky pass doesn't get through.
When the defensive rotation is missed for the third time.
When a player misses two shots and the game is close.
When a mistake stops being a nice idea about development and has just cost us something.
That is when the real test begins.
Not the child's.
The environment's.
Because saying “mistakes are normal” during a preseason parent meeting is fairly easy.
It gets a little harder when the score is 68–68 with 43 seconds left.
That's when a team's real mistake policy begins to show.
The athlete sees the consequence, not the intention
A coach may genuinely believe they give players freedom.
A parent may genuinely believe they aren't adding pressure.
Both may have the best intentions.
But the child doesn't experience their intentions.
They experience what happens.
A coach may say: “Play free.”
But the athlete notices that after two mistakes, they come straight out of the game.
A parent may say: “All I care about is that you enjoy it.”
But the ride home begins with: “What happened on that play in the third quarter?”
A team may say it encourages creativity.
But after one risky pass, three teammates throw their arms up at exactly the same time.
A spontaneous piece of choreography nobody remembers rehearsing.
Young athletes become very good at reading these things.
Especially as their sport begins to matter more.
The coach's face.
The tone.
The silence.
The substitution.
The sigh from the stands.
Who gets the next pass.
Who doesn't.
Who gets corrected and stays in the game.
Who makes a mistake and immediately starts looking toward the bench.
Research in youth sport points to something important: the environment adults believe they are creating is not always the same environment athletes experience.
That doesn't mean the adult is lying.
And it doesn't mean the athlete is interpreting everything “wrong.”
It simply means there can be a gap between what we intend to communicate and what the young athlete receives.
And fear of mistakes can grow inside that gap.
A mistake is allowed to cost something
This is where we need to avoid swinging too far in the other direction.
A healthy environment does not mean: “Do whatever you want, kids. Everything is wonderful.”
Sport has consequences.
Sometimes very real ones.
You lost your player on defense and they scored.
You turned the ball over.
You didn't execute what the team had agreed to do.
You made a poor decision.
You may be substituted.
You may get corrected.
You may temporarily lose a role.
At a certain level, you may even miss out on selection.
Accepting mistakes does not mean removing responsibility.
The more important question is: What does the athlete learn from the consequence?
“I need to understand what happened.”
or:
“If I make a mistake, my place is at risk.”
From the stands, those two situations may look almost identical.
A player misses a defensive rotation.
The coach takes them out.
In the first situation, the coach says: “Sit for one possession. Watch the help-side rotation. See where your player goes. You're going back in.”
In the second:
whistle.
look.
bench.
No words.
Same substitution.
Maybe even the same tactical reason behind it.
But not necessarily the same message.
And this is where the conversation about mistakes becomes much more interesting than simply saying, “Let kids fail.”
We don't need to remove consequences.
We need to understand what those consequences come to mean.
Whatever happens around them, athletes also need to find their way back into the next play. Sometimes that entire battle takes place in just a few seconds. We explored that moment separately in The 7 Seconds After a Mistake.
The team's unwritten mistake policy
Every team has rules.
Practice time.
Uniforms.
Systems.
Who takes the inbound.
How we defend the pick-and-roll.
And then there are the rules nobody wrote down.
How serious a mistake is.
How long it stays “alive.”
Whether you are allowed to try again.
Whether a teammate looks at you differently after you miss.
Whether your parent will bring the play up in the car.
Whether your coach corrects the mistake or judges the person.
Whether a tactical mistake is treated the same way as a lack of effort.
Whether risk is actually allowed or simply mentioned in speeches.
Together, these things create a team's unwritten mistake policy.
And the coach is not the only person writing it.
Everyone contributes.
Coach.
Parent.
Teammate.
Sometimes even the older or more influential players on the team.
A coach may respond brilliantly to a mistake while teammates immediately send a completely different message.
A parent may handle the moment perfectly while the athlete still feels that every mistake threatens their minutes.
Or the other way around.
There isn't always one person to blame.
There is often a system of small reactions which, stacked on top of one another, tells a young athlete: “You can try here.” or: “Better be careful not to mess anything up.”
Sometimes it takes months before you can see the difference between the two.
The first athlete keeps asking for the ball.
The second still runs, gets into position and does everything they're supposed to do.
But their game starts becoming a little smaller.
Who gets a bigger margin for error?
It's one of the more uncomfortable questions.
Does every athlete on a team really have the same freedom to make mistakes?
Maybe not.
And those differences are not automatically unfair.
An experienced athlete may carry more responsibility.
A starter may be on the floor precisely because they have already shown they can handle certain situations.
A newcomer may need different boundaries.
Roles exist.
Trust is built.
Performance matters.
But every once in a while, it is worth watching the bench after a mistake.
The starter turns the ball over twice.
Stays in.
The reserve checks in.
Turns it over once.
Their eyes go straight to the coach.
Maybe the coach isn't even thinking about taking them out.
But the athlete checks.
They have learned something.
Maybe from their own experience.
Maybe from what they have watched happen to other players.
Maybe because they feel their margin for error is smaller.
And when an athlete starts believing they only have one mistake available, their game can change before the mistake even happens.
They stop trying the pass.
They stop attacking the space.
They stop taking the shot.
They stop playing the situation.
They start playing the risk of being taken out.
When fear begins changing an athlete's decisions - making them play safer, hesitate or avoid the ball - the mechanism has already moved inside them. We explored that side of the problem separately in Fear of Mistakes in Sports: Why It Holds You Back and How to Turn It into Progress.
But here, we're looking somewhere else.
We're looking at the place where they may have learned that they needed to be afraid in the first place.
When the messages don't match
Most of us have probably said something like this at least once: “Try it.”
And then, when the attempt went badly: “Why would you do that?”
Not because we're hypocrites.
Because we're human.
And because loving the process is much easier when the process hasn't just cost us the game.
That's where some of the most confusing messages in youth sports begin.
“Play free.”
But:
“Don't take risks.”
“Make the decision.”
But:
“Not that decision.”
“It doesn't matter if you miss.”
But the reaction after the miss says something else.
“What matters is that you learn.”
But after the game we spend twenty minutes talking about the mistake.
“I don't care about the score.”
And then we somehow know the score of every quarter, the free-throw percentage and probably the temperature inside the gym when the miss happened.
Sometimes this contradiction goes far beyond mistakes and becomes part of the child's entire competitive experience. We explored how pressure can travel from the stands onto the court in Pressure in Youth Sports: How Parents Can Recognize It and Reduce It.
Young athletes do not need the adults around them to be perfect.
That would be a fairly funny expectation in an article about mistakes.
But they do need the environment to be coherent enough for them to understand the difference between: “You made a mistake.” and: “Your mistake changes what we think about you.”
The first is sport.
The second can become a burden.
The real test isn't what you say before the mistake
Want to know what kind of relationship with mistakes a team is building?
Don't ask what the coach said at the beginning of the season.
Don't read the slogan on the locker-room wall.
Don't ask the parents whether they support their child's development.
Watch what happens after someone makes a mistake.
Who speaks?
How do they speak?
How long does the moment last?
Is the action being corrected, or is the athlete being labelled?
Do they get another opportunity?
Does the mistake remain information, or does it become an event?
And maybe the most important question: What does the athlete learn they need to do next time?
Adjust?
Or protect themselves?
None of this means we need to smile after every turnover.
It doesn't mean a coach should never substitute a player.
And it definitely doesn't mean every ride home has to turn into a mindfulness session.
It simply means it is worth noticing the messages we send when things don't go well.
Because young athletes don't learn the rules of their environment only from what we tell them.
They learn by watching.
The bench.
The stands.
Their teammates.
The next pass.
Who stays on the court.
Who gets an explanation.
Who gets only a look.
And slowly, they begin to understand how much a mistake costs here.
Some rules are written down.
The most important ones, perhaps, aren't.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why can a young athlete be afraid of making mistakes even when they are told mistakes are okay?
Because athletes don't learn only from what they hear.
They also learn from what happens after the mistake: the coach's reaction, a parent's expression, teammates' responses, a substitution or the next opportunity they are given.
An adult may genuinely say, “It's okay, move on,” while the athlete simultaneously notices that something changed.
That is why an adult's intention and an athlete's experience are not always the same thing.
2. Is it wrong for a coach to take a young athlete out of the game after a mistake?
No.
Sport has real consequences, and a substitution may be a completely normal tactical decision or a useful moment for correction.
The important question is what the athlete understands from that moment:
“I need to adjust something.”
or:
“If I make a mistake, I lose my place.”
Accepting mistakes does not mean removing responsibility. It means avoiding turning every error into a verdict on the athlete.
3. How can a parent or coach tell what message they are sending after a mistake?
They can start with one simple question: “What might this athlete understand from my reaction right now?”
You don't have to smile after every turnover, and you don't need to ignore mistakes.
But it is worth noticing whether your reaction helps the athlete understand what they can adjust or makes them think mainly about what will happen if they make another mistake.
Sometimes the difference isn't in a speech.
It's in a look, a few words or the next opportunity.
Comments